Culture

Supergirl review: charmless maid of steel adrift in DC Studios comic book universe

Supergirl and Krypto

The best reason to go see Supergirl is Krypto – and he spends most of the movie playing dead.

The film follows Kara Zor-El, Superman’s sullen cousin, as she reluctantly joins a young alien girl on an interstellar mission of revenge against the mercenary Krem of the Yellow Hills. Along the way, Kara needs to find an antidote to save her poisoned super pooch, avoid miscellaneous space pirates and trade barbs with intergalactic biker Lobo.

It’s a road movie by way of a space western, stitched together with skirmishes, detours and bursts of cosmic spectacle, albeit one that feels endlessly derivative of other genre films – Guardians of the Galaxy, Mad Max Fury Road, Star Wars etc. 

Craig (Cruella) Gillespie directs, from a screenplay by Ana Nogueira. The story is ostensibly based on ‘Supergirl Woman of Tomorrow’, the comic mini-series written by Tom King.

Nogueira is currently writing a reboot of Wonder Woman, as well as a live-action Teen Titans for DC Studios.

It’s a road movie by way of a space western, albeit one that feels endlessly derivative of other genre films…

There are flashes of something interesting beneath the surface. The glimpses of Kara’s childhood on Krypton, and her life in Argo City, are among the film’s strongest moments. We get her first meeting with Krypto, as well as her Earthly introduction to Clark (a welcome cameo from David Corenswet). Some of the action scenes have bubble gum bravado. But in the end I didn’t care.

Alcock portrays Kara as a charmless brat. Her take lacks the heart that Melissa Benoist brought to the CW series, and the supporting cast – Jason Momoa’s Lobo and Matthias Schoenaerts’ villain – fail to elevate the material. 

Jason Momoa cosplays as the bastich-cursing Lobo, all leather, face paint and CGI cigar smoke, while Matthias Schoenaerts is a villain in search of scenery to chew on.

Most grievously, the film spends most of its time undermining Kara’s superpowers. Her supersuit remains in the wardrobe for much of the running time, incongruously side-lined by a Blondie T-shirt, and pair of conspicuously retro headphones.

Perhaps the biggest disappointment is the lack of James Gunn’s signature stamp. His Superman crackled with energy, humour and emotional clarity. Here that wit and comic book vision is no where to be seen.

There’s also no post-credit scene, offering little sense of where this franchise is heading next. As a result, Supergirl ends not with anticipation but a super shrug.

Three star rating for The 355

Supergirl is directed by Craig Gillespie, and stars Milly Alcock, Jason Momoa, Matthias Schoenaerts, and Krypto. 12A, 108  minutes.

London lifestyle guide: Eats, Beats and Treats around the capital you won’t want to miss

A new rock music photography exhibition, an exclusive NYE fireworks party, and a mouth-watering Christmas menu. There’s always something happening in London, and The Luxe Review has the inside track on all the new bars, restaurants, hotels, and divine distractions that make spending time in the capital such a vibe. Welcome to Eats, Beats and…

I Swear and A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms shine at the 46th BASE home entertainment trade awards

The British Association for Screen Entertainment (BASE) rolled out the red carpet at its new venue, The Londoner, for the 46th annual BASE Awards, bringing together distributors, retailers, platforms, agencies and production partners from across the home entertainment sector. Hosted by Ayo Akinwolere, I Swear and Wicked were the big winners on the night. Studiocanal’s…

Unknown's avatar

About Steve May

Creator of Home Cinema Choice magazine, and Editor of The Luxe Review, Steve muses and reviews for Trusted Reviews, T3, Home Cinema Choice, Games Radar, Good Housekeeping, Louder Sounds, StereoNet and Boat International. He’s also the editor of professional home cinema website Inside CI. He's on Twitter/X, Tiktok and Instagram as @SteveMay_UK